
Can Scotland learn from its near neighbour?
At the turn of this century, Scotland and Denmark were closely matched. With similar populations and economic scale, both had long left behind the heavy industry that once defined them. Twenty-five years on, the two countries have drifted far apart. Denmark’s population has grown much faster than Scotland’s, and income per head in Denmark is now around 60 per cent higher. That gap did not open overnight - why should one small northern European nation have pulled so far ahead of the other?
The differences are not just economic; in health, the gap is also widening. Denmark has lower rates of obesity, lower infant and maternal mortality, and generally better outcomes after heart attacks and strokes. Scotland, by contrast, has ambition with its ten year population health strategy but the solutions to drug deaths and alcohol harms are complex. Our healthy life expectancy is improving but trails behind Denmark and other comparable European countries.
The economic difference might generate some predictable explanations, but even so Brexit is only part of the story. Denmark is in the European Union, but it is not in the Euro. The Danish currency, the Krone, is tied tightly to the Euro through an exchange rate agreement, within a narrow band of just 2.25 per cent, which in practice leaves the Danish central bank following interest rate decisions made in Frankfurt. So Denmark’s apparent monetary freedom is more theoretical than real - not unlike the position Scotland would likely face if independence meant either joining the Euro or continuing to use the Pound. For small nations with their own currency, EU membership by itself does not deliver financial autonomy.
What Denmark does have, and matters more, is full control over fiscal policy: what to tax, what to spend, and how to shape labour markets. Even without an independent currency, a government that controls its own budget and its own economic institutions can build a very different kind of capitalism from its neighbours. Denmark has made bold choices to create a Nordic economy; free market and capitalist, but combined with a very large and generous welfare state. Underpinning this is a framework of ‘flexicurity’ that uses a social safety net plus training to create a confident flexible labour force. Key to financing this has been high productivity.
Denmark’s free capitalism comes with some unique characteristics. Many of Denmark’s largest firms are controlled by foundations set up to protect long-term purpose, alongside a strong tradition of co-operative and worker-owned enterprise. In theory this should allow longer term corporate thinking, and there is no sign that it has held back innovation or enterprise. Denmark has a dynamic economy and skilled workforce supported by technology investment.
Trust is the other ingredient in explaining Denmark’s success: hard to measure but evident to any visitor. Danes rank among the most trusting people on earth; in their neighbours, their institutions and their state. Tax is paid without much complaint, in part because people can see clearly what they get for it: strong schools, good healthcare, generous parental leave, and support that lets people take risks with their careers. That trust has been built over generations through strong social and educational institutions, encouraging everyone to stay connected to their community. Scotland has plenty of warmth and community spirit of its own, but could learn from Danish practice to embed this more deeply.
Denmark is not a fairy tale, and it faces its own strains - in particular, a low birth rate and ageing population. Integrating people into a high skill economy and high trust society is a challenge. The model also involves fiscal discipline; Denmark’s government debt is under 30% of Gross Domestic Product and VAT is a high 25%. Would there be public support in Scotland for that?
Denmark shows that a small northern nation can build a fairer and richer society given consistent policy and patience. There is value in understanding the choices that Denmark has made. Scotland has the talent and the institutions to make a Nordic approach work here.